Scallops: A French Gastronomic Jewel

Choosing the Right Wine for Scallops

The scallop, named after the pilgrims of Santiago de Compostela who wore them as a sign of their pilgrimage, is a hallmark of French cuisine. Known for its quality and delicate taste, it can be prepared in countless ways depending on the inspiration of the chef. It’s especially prized during the holiday season.

Raw, pan-seared, cooked, in cream, or plain, scallops serve as the basis for a wide range of culinary experiences. Given these possibilities, a common question arises: What wine should you serve with scallops?

Wine Selection Based on Preparation

The success of scallops is primarily due to their firm yet creamy flesh and their subtly briny taste. These characteristics make them well-suited for pairing with a velvety, aromatic white wine with good acidity.

The choice of wine can be both still and sparkling, with a suitable Champagne being an option. However, this is the only general rule for scallops. The wine you choose will vary considerably depending on how the scallops are prepared.

The fresher the scallops are in their raw state, the more refined and aromatic dry white wines such as Alsace Rieslings, Burgundy Chablis, or Loire Sancerres will be appropriate.

For recipes that involve cooking, braising, flambéing, or creamy preparations, white wines with aged characteristics will resonate well. We are talking about Burgundy Chardonnays or Chenin Blancs from Anjou. White wines from the South with their freshness can also work very well.

The same logic applies if you opt for a sparkling wine. An aromatic, well-acidic sparkling wine will pair excellently with fresh scallops, as the bubbles will cut through the richness of the flesh. A more pastry-like Champagne, with developed secondary aromas (brioche, biscuit, nuts, etc.), will pair better with cooked scallops.

Recipe 1: Scallop Carpaccio

When raw, the scallop reveals its natural flavors. To prepare scallop carpaccio, remove the coral, rinse the scallop, and slice it thinly. Arrange the slices in a rosette pattern on a serving plate.

For the accompaniment, dare to be original. Truffle slices, olive oil, salt, and pepper will create an elegant carpaccio suitable for the holidays. To accentuate the freshness of the carpaccio, pair it with lime, chives, and coriander.

Alternatively, surprise your guests with a seafood and fruit combination by preparing a carpaccio with clementines and saffron. All combinations are possible to astonish your diners.

With this preparation, pair the scallops with Chablis, Riesling, or Sancerre. Chablis is particularly suited when the carpaccio's flavors align with the natural brininess of the mollusk or a lemony carpaccio.

Rieslings and Sancerres, being more aromatic, will pair excellently with fruitier carpaccio recipes.

A truffle carpaccio can also be complemented with a Burgundy Chardonnay, such as a Meursault.

Recipe 2: Roasted Scallops with Chestnuts

This second recipe highlights scallops in their cooked form. We’ve chosen a roasted version with chestnuts, especially suited for Christmas tables.

Sautéed in butter with chestnuts, seasoned with apple juice caramel, and served with apple sticks, these scallops offer ideal flavors for the holiday season.

The richness obtained from cooking the scallops and the comfort of winter flavors pair elegantly with the richness and comfort of oaked Chardonnays.

Consider Burgundy Chardonnays or those from the Pays d’OC. This same gustatory comfort can also be found in Chenin Blancs from Anjou, aged in barrels. The aging imparts a buttery quality and slight woody notes that complement the aromatic profile of the dish.

General Wine Pairing with Scallops

As you can see, there is no one-size-fits-all wine pairing for scallops. Given the variety of possible recipes for this dish, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed or make a misstep.

Choosing a velvety, aromatic white wine is a fail-safe choice. In case of doubt, a Burgundy Chardonnay is a reliable option, offering good acidity, aromatic complexity, and a hint of oak that will suit most preparations.